Brand ranking · Meinl
Meinl Cymbals: Best to Worst
9 Meinl cymbal lines ranked. The Byzance dynasty at the top, the HCS as the budget revelation, and the brass entries to skip.
How we’ve ranked these
Three tiers. 9 cymbal lines
Top tier
Lifetime gear
Cymbals that retain their character for decades. Worth the investment if you’ll keep them. Premium alloys, hand- or hybrid-hammered, made for working drummers.
5 lines in this tier
Mid
Solid working tools
Reliable cymbals at a fair price. Won’t change your sound but won’t embarrass you either. Fine for rehearsal, second-tier kits, or backup pairs.
2 lines in this tier
Avoid
Outgrown in a year
Beginner traps and discontinued lines. Either the sound character is fundamentally limited, the build won’t hold up, or a competitor at the same tier does the job better.
2 lines in this tier
Every Meinl line, ranked
9 lines, from the Byzance Vintage down to the CC Practice
- 01
Top tierByzance Vintage
Byzance Vintage is what brought Meinl into the conversation with Zildjian and Sabian at the top tier. Hand-hammered in Turkey, raw-finish, and tonally singular — the cymbal Anika Nilles, Mario Duplantier, and Benny Greb chose for the records that defined the last decade of progressive playing.
- 02
Top tierByzance Traditional
Where Byzance Vintage is dark and complex, Byzance Traditional gives you the same hand-hammering with a brighter, more cutting voice. Studio-favourite for rock and fusion contexts where projection matters more than warmth.
- 03
Top tierByzance Dark
Byzance Dark goes further into the warm-and-complex end of the spectrum than Vintage — quicker decay, less stick attack, sits perfectly under busy guitar mixes. The cymbal of choice for jazz-fusion players who want a Meinl voice with more shadow.
- 04
Top tierByzance Brilliant
Byzance Brilliant is the polished-surface variant of the Byzance line — the lathing is tighter, the surface is mirror-finish, and the resulting voice is brighter and more ‘recorded’ sounding. Strong choice for contemporary worship, pop, and modern rock.
- 05
Top tierPure Alloy Custom
Pure Alloy Custom uses a single-alloy B12 process — not Byzance-tier, but in the same conversation at noticeably less money. Hand-hammered, slightly thinner stock, and a notably even voice that records well across genres.
- 06
MidClassics Custom
Classics Custom uses B10 bronze, halfway between the budget B8 lines and the Byzance B20. Bright, fast, projection-forward — not as nuanced as the higher tiers but very useful at the price.
- 07
MidHCS
Meinl’s HCS is the surprise budget line — MS63 alloy hammered to give a noticeably more musical voice than equivalent Zildjian ZBT or Sabian B8. If you’re kitting out a beginner’s first cymbal pack on a $200 budget, this is what to buy.
- 08
AvoidHCS Brass
HCS Brass is the bottom of the Meinl catalogue — literally brass, not bronze. The price gap to the proper HCS line is small enough that there’s no reason to choose this one.
- 09
AvoidCC Practice
Meinl’s practice line works, but the Sabian Quiet Tone has better articulation and feel at the same price. If you need practice cymbals, get those instead.
Frequently asked